Understanding Why Lettered Notation is Illogical


Music is not Science. There’s some interesting sciencey things about music, but music itself doesn’t have to perfect or logical. Classical notation using letters is a great example. It hasn’t changed for hundreds of years altho the values and assignments are largely arbitrary. Here’s the notes on a keyboard:

piano_notes

Most pianos and keyboards will be tuned to A440 in equal temperament. Some have an issue with this but my beef is the assignment of the black and white keys, or really the concept of flats and sharps as they are assigned to the letters A-G.

The argument against redesigning this system from scratch may be that music is more about intuition than logic and that the existing system has prevailed precisely because of this and anyway, it’s all pretty logical it you study it long enough. But this is the problem. It only seems right because you accept these arbitrary assignments as a kind of Truth that is unquestioned. Staring from this, a logical construct is formed around it that supports itself and eventually, seems intuitive. But really, the process involves rote memorization which is wholly unintuitive. For example, the notes A and B are a whole step apart, but B and C are a half step. Why? There is a historical reason, but also, the notes themselves must be considered as nonsense. The white keys on the piano may seem “brighter” sounding or more “natural” in some way but this is only through repetition, ear training, and relative placement of notes. An older standard of note values places the A above middle C at around 415 Hz, a full half-step below A440. If a keyboard is tuned to the values of the notes when those notes were invented, the keyboard looks like this:

(it actually will look the same, unless you paint the note values on there)

(it actually will look the same if you don’t paint the note values on there)

Unless you have perfect pitch (trained to 440), you might not even notice a piano has been tuned this way. It might sound off at first, but you’d get used to it. Time has proven this. The system of equal temperament is another example, but regarding the intervals. We are accustomed to hearing notes and intervals slightly wrong from what they were first intended to the point were the “right” values now sound wrong. Eliminating the arbitrary system of letter values with sharps and flats would make learning notes and intervals easier for new students.

%

, ,

  1. #1 by US Hot Air Balloon Team on 2015.11.25 - 09:45

    Good blog. Thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner as well.

    • #2 by Jim on 2015.11.25 - 21:41

      I would like to think that this is a legit comment from the US Hot Air Balloon Team of Lancaster Counter and they did not feel the need to hire an adbot. I am choosing to think that.

  2. #3 by Galamadammen on 2016.02.17 - 12:15

    Manual errors may also lead to shrinkage in cash flow. Forgive me if I’m
    soundding too touchy-feely here. For this discussion, however,
    we will keep it simple because we are just trying to give you an idea of how it
    works. There iis no easier way to earrn extra cash for someone who loves to read.
    Also known as cash loans, urgent cash loans, quick loans etc it
    is instantly available. Don’t let oobstacles slow you down from reaching your
    goals. This automated binary softwware is one oof tthe best free binary
    software for newbie annd profsssional options traders.
    In the more developed countries, intensive cultivation and mechanized farming techniques are ccommonly used.

    This thought sometimes makes them feel stress and unhappiness.
    Unsecured Business Loans They are loans that aren’t secured
    bby having an asset like property or even a car from the borrower themselves.
    Usually, these business loans are sent applications for with a buddy or relative who has an asset.
    The salvage value of the existing asset at the ennd of itts life, if it were nott replaced.
    o Business examples inclhde payments from customers ffor goods and services, receipt of interedst
    from a bank loan,returnson savings and investments, shareholder investments, and rental income oon invetment properties.

    Many pros and cons are bound to appear as
    the technology of electronic cash develops even further.
    If your hair is in shorter supply than others, then it means selling
    your hair is likely to make you more money than those with dark brown hair.
    Most of the companies provide excellent custpmer care.

    However, when you apply for a business loan, you would encounter difficulties because finaancial lenders are
    so strict in approving loans. Jusst stay with one of the payday providers, such as American Loan Search, onl with top lenders they work,
    have the ones you know or seewn the commercials with. After sending an invoice to a
    factoring company, the company caan receive the balance of the receivables less the commission of the factor annd a security deposit withn 48 hours.
    To confide aall of this, these aree some of the claims that Russ
    Dalbey offers you with Winning within tthe Money
    Move Enterprise: “Find ‘Em, Record ‘Em, and Make Money!”, “So easy that anyone can do that!”, “I guarantee that you’ll start making money straight away!”
    Once you have got finished hat you would have to resell
    the promissory observe to another person, so
    your web profit will merely be the difference between the purchase price and the resell price.
    Instant cash loans are the outcome oof quick decision taken by the lender
    to resolve the financial problem of any person. o Personal examples inclkude salaries, bonuses, dividends, sale oof any item, interest on savings,
    and rental from owned properties are all examples of money crossing your personal
    revenue border. It is tto ensure that the lenders don’t face the problems of bad debt.
    This limit is not released onn Granite card’s web ssite though, because thee limit offered to each cusstomer is different.

    The more income the buyer has, the better the offer it cann afford to make for your
    vehicle. There are other articles here on the subject with more detail iff you wish.
    Thhe tenure for the repayment depends usually upon the amount borrowed and the
    nearest payday date. Eventually, when applying low cost elements, where ddo
    yyou intend to get your low cost figures? Once you receive your paycheck,
    you will need to repay the amount.

  3. #5 by stephen curry shoes sale on 2016.03.24 - 10:23

    Wow, this paragraph is good, my younger sister is analyzing these kinds
    of things, therefore I am going to inforfm her.

(will not be published)